Paul Taylor, a livestock auctioneer from Irving, Texas, began Paul Taylor Saddle Co. in 1957 by selling merchandise out of his cargo trailer en route to auctions. In the early 1980’s, he purchased his dream property near Pilot Point, Texas and in 1985 he and his wife, Anna, opened Paul Taylor Saddle Co. at its current location. The store has expanded multiple times due to the growth of the North Texas Horse Country, also known as "Horse Country, USA". The most recent was a remodeling and addition of a home decor section in the summer of 2007.

Paul Taylor Saddle Co. has grown from a small warehouse to become one of the largest family-owned retail tack stores with over 700 wholesale accounts  worldwide. Offering as many as 1,200 saddles, along with thousands of horse supplies, it caters not only to the professional horsemen but also first time horse owners with one-stop shopping. Paul Taylor Saddle Co. has become nationally renowned and is recognized by horse enthusiasts around the world.